Wednesday, March 14, 2007

The Misery of Agnosticism

I made an attempt at atheism, influenced by a few different contributing factors. One was the circle of flavorful people I'd met who seemed apathetic if not incredulous toward the God I'd learned about in church. Then there were those in church who seemed equally apathetic, if not mean. Also, there is of course the persistent inundation of introductory level science that always left the impression that man has it all figured out, and complex life is not so complex, but sprouts like bread mold under the right conditions. At any rate, my attempt was short-lived. Atheism would be impossible to maintain without ample doses of misinformation and a strict adherence to daily rigorous exercises in closed-mindedness. The spiritual is simply too obvious, whether in order in the cosmos, beauty in creation, a miracle in a hospital or a timely word from a friend or stranger. And so I arrived at agnosticism, perhaps the most miserable of all religious points of view. Militant skepticism avails itself no pleasure, or at least rest for the mind, in the beauty of nature, or purpose in life, or faith in truth, lest one be deceived. Yet surely there would be more peace in being sincerely wrong than in the constant distrust of experience, emotions, or knowledge. While agnosticism feigns open-mindedness, it is actually a stubborn refusal to reach some informed conclusion. At last I'd indulged the nagging suspicion that God wasn't there, only to be confronted with the nagging dread that He was. I was haunted most by the empty tomb of Jesus of Nazareth. It loomed occasionally in my mind, inexplicable, indismissable, a reminder of a real and personal God, who was "pleased to have all His fullness dwell in (Jesus) and through Him to reconcile to Himself all things, by making peace through His blood, shed on the cross" Colossians 1:19-20.

4 comments:

Alyce Faulkner said...

"Atheism would be impossible to maintain without ample doses of misinformation and a strict adherence to daily rigorous exercises in closed-mindedness."

This one spoke to me-but not from the standpoint of being an atheist, but as a believer.
Can we be misinformed? Can we grasp hold of that misinformation, treat it as gospel, partake of it until it becomes part of us? We then pound our chest and demand that everyone adhere to this same 'misinformation'. So we take 'our gospel ie 'misinformation' and we daily adhere to rigorous exercises in closed-mindedness (stubborn)? Oh yes.
I took off on an entire different spin, I know-but you took me there with that one thought!
I'm looking for more.

Bryan Riley said...

You write prose poetically. Me likes.

Greg said...

alyce,
Yes we can be misinformed. I think this is what I meant in the previous entry when I mused that life might be simpler as an atheist. It is of little consequence to the one who doesn't believe in God whether the earth is 14 billion years old or 5 billion years old. But as one who is learning to walk in a relationship of trust and love with our Creator, I must constantly check the tremendous amount of information I recieve to what He says in His word, and I perhaps agonize too much over what should be deemed a neccessity to orthodoxy. Does God really say the earth is only 6,000 years old?
Misinformation is far more plentiful than truth, and as you point out it is not only scientific. It comes from within as much or more as from outside of us. While there is beautiful simplicity in knowing the Truth, the one who has "the words of eternal life" john 6:68, there is also, for His followers, no time for passivity in the face of vain speculation and outright deception. "examine yourselves to see whether you are in the faith; test yourselves"(2 Cor 13:5). "...test the spirits to see whether they are from God"(1 John 4:1)..."We demolish arguments and every pretension that sets itself up against the knowledge of God, and we take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ"(2 Cor 10:5).

Alyce Faulkner said...

No time to be passive. yes you are right.
I noted Tuesday night, as we prayed, those prayers were not passive, they were bold, grabbing the hem of his garment, expectant.

Also, last night in our Romans study. I'm also noticing a difference. Roy is like a wild man. He is sinking into it and pulling us under to the depths of where this water will actually take us to the truth. I'm not even trying to swim and see people abandoning the boat and beginning to walk on the waters of faith.